The Evolving Landscape of Journalism: Truth, Speed, and Trust in the Digital Age
A core tenet of journalism is taking responsibility for your writing. This lesson, however, is frequently ignored, even by established news agencies. We've seen instances where reputable outlets, eager to break a story first, have inadvertently copied incorrect information from "new media" sources, leading to serious repercussions. The drive to be first often overshadows the commitment to being accurate.
Opinion vs. Reporting: Navigating Local News in a Social Media World
In today's social media-saturated environment, finding unadulterated news, even about a specific area like Raleigh, NC, can be challenging. The lines between opinion and factual reporting have blurred. Social media channels are now primary platforms for sharing news: Facebook and Instagram for making a point, Twitter for headlines and directing traffic, and blogs for nearly everything else.
Consider the burgeoning world of food blogging. It seems everyone wants to share recipes or review their favorite eateries. These bloggers, though not covering celebrity gossip, can become local celebrities in their own right, respected for their culinary insights. Restaurants welcome them in hopes of a glowing review, and budding chefs can gain significant followings by sharing great recipes. Just look at Ree Drummond, "The Pioneer Woman," who transitioned from a website to a long-running show on Food Network—a testament to the power of niche digital journalism.
Even controversial figures like Perez Hilton, whose 15 minutes of fame arguably passed long ago, remain relevant due to their chosen topics. Celebrities themselves sometimes leverage him for attention. I recall a news segment about actress Tori Spelling's DVD signing where, despite a clear lack of public attendance, Perez Hilton was prominently featured, creating a false impression of a bustling event. This illustrates how individuals, even those often dismissed as mere gossips, can still wield influence and remain in business by exploiting the blurred lines of modern media.
The Future of Journalism: Ethics in a Digital Age
The future of journalism hinges on those who still possess a genuine passion for the craft. Mass communication students, researchers, and aspiring journalists must pay close attention. While the delivery method of news is rapidly evolving, the fundamental, grassroots idea of being a journalist—to inform truthfully—will always remain constant. As the video "The Future of Journalism" (presumably) states, we are unequivocally in a digital age. Whether it's local, national, or even hyper-local news, our traditional reliance on newspapers and television is giving way to something new, different, and often exciting.
This evolution presents immense opportunities for aspiring journalists who previously had limited outlets to practice their specialty. The changing landscape of news delivery can lead to more journalism jobs, opening up novel and engaging ways to present news, not only ethically but also creatively.
First vs. Correct: The Industry's Core Dilemma
However, a critical debate rages in the industry today: what's more important—being first, or being correct? The tragic case of Joe Paterno, the iconic college football coach, serves as a stark example. When Paterno was battling for his life, CBS prematurely reported his death via Twitter and their website. His children quickly confirmed he was still alive. CBS issued an apology, yet, in a perverse twist, they still "won."
In the journalism industry, it's the readers who grant power. A larger audience directly translates to greater revenue through advertising, as you can guarantee more views. In their honest post-mortem, Fox Sports observed that despite CBS's egregious error, they were rewarded with increased page views. This means that even a grave mistake can lead to an expanded audience, simply because they prioritized speed. No matter the apology, CBS gained readers by choosing to be first rather than accurate.
Consumers are, frankly, a complex group. I believe they're split roughly 50/50 on the "first or right" question. Honest journalism should always be the expectation. Yet, consumers also crave controversy and are drawn to dramatic narratives. The social media revolution has empowered every consumer to become a journalist, publicly offering their "two cents" on any story.
Understanding Media Influence: Agenda-Setting and Framing
Two key theories help us understand how media influences public perception:
Agenda-Setting Theory: "Readers learn not only about a given issue, but also how much importance to attach to that issue from the amount of information in a news story and its position."
Framing Theory: "How something is presented to the audience, called 'the frame,' influences the choices people make about how to process that information."
The Joe Paterno story was already highly charged due to his association with the Jerry Sandusky scandal. Paterno's health became a hot topic. CBS, through a 140-character tweet and their website, effectively used the agenda-setting theory, telling users Paterno was dead: "@CBSSports: Joe Paterno has died at the age of 85 –
The infamous "Rathergate" scandal involving Dan Rather and CBS further highlights the perils of prioritizing speed over accuracy. In that instance, unauthenticated documents critical of President George W. Bush's Air National Guard service led to severe consequences, including job losses for key CBS employees and Rather's forced departure. Examples like these underscore that failure to report accurately can have severe repercussions, not only for the individuals and organizations involved in the story but also for those responsible for its dissemination.
The overall shift to digital news reporting, while providing more avenues for sharing news, must come with increased responsibility. I believe and hope that this evolution is fostering a greater understanding: being first is not always in the best interest of the public. The accuracy of the story we present is far more valuable and worth its weight in gold.
Comments
Post a Comment